If you’re one of the many people who loves the taste of toffee, you likely enjoy making toffee sauce. Toffee sauce is great to have around for a number of reasons.
It’s fantastic when you need something to put on ice cream, and it also goes very well with various other types of desserts.
When you want to make toffee sauce, you will probably want to use cream of some sort. What can you do if you don’t have any cream, though?
Is there something that can be used as a substitute? Will the toffee sauce still turn out okay?
Keep reading to learn about the best options.
What Substitutes Can You Use?
For the most part, the only substitute that is commonly used is milk. Most toffee sauce recipes call for you to use heavy cream.
If you want to get the results that are intended by most toffee sauce recipes, it’s best to use heavy cream. That’s the most common way to make it.
Many people who use milk instead of toffee sauce say that everything turns out nicely. However, it might be best to seek out a recipe that calls for milk instead of heavy cream.
This ensures that the toffee sauce will turn out as good as possible with the ingredients that you have available. There are several good recipes out there that you can try.
For example, this recipe calls for you to use sweetened condensed milk. Other recipes might ask you to use some other type of milk.
Generally, some type of milk is going to be used as a substitute. Sometimes people use milk in conjunction with other ingredients such as corn starch for certain types of sauces.
What to Expect
You want to make toffee sauce that turns out as good as possible. If you’re new to making this type of sauce, it’s normal to make mistakes.
Things can go wrong if you aren’t careful. You might wind up with toffee sauce that is less than satisfying.
Below, you’re going to learn about some potential issues that you’ll need to avoid. Knowing to expect certain problems should make it easier to get the sauce to turn out great.
Thin Sauce
Sometimes toffee sauce will turn out far too thin. This occurs when you use too much milk.
As mentioned earlier, milk is a common substitute for heavy cream in toffee sauce recipes. You could be using various different kinds of milk depending on what the recipe calls for.
To make things go as planned, you need to carefully measure out the amount of milk that you need. Making a mistake and adding too much to the mix will ruin things.
When you add more milk than you’re supposed to, it’ll make the sauce turn out thin and weak. It won’t be as flavorful or satisfying as you want it to be.
Only use the amount of milk that the recipe calls for. If you’re trying to make your own toffee sauce recipe, consider cutting down the amount of milk you’re using.
If your toffee sauce is turning out very thin, it’d be wise to cut the milk content down by half. This might be enough to solve the problem.
Can You Thicken Toffee Sauce?
What if the toffee sauce already turned out kind of thin? Is there anything that you can do about it?
You should be able to thicken the sauce up if you take the right approach. Simply use thickening agents to try to turn things around.
One of the most common choices involves using cornstarch to thicken the sauce. You could also use other thickening agents such as flour or tapioca flour.
Using thickening agents involves adding them to the sauce along with a bit of water. You then stir the toffee sauce to try to ensure that it doesn’t become clumpy.
Don’t add too much of the thickening agent. If using cornstarch, it’ll likely be best to use one teaspoon of cornstarch and a half of a teaspoon of water for 240 ml of toffee sauce.
If you don’t want to risk making the sauce clumpy, you could simply simmer it. Sometimes simmering it will help it to thicken up.
Best Ways to Use Toffee Sauce
Toffee sauce is really tasty. Sometimes you might make a big batch of it and feel like you have too much, though.
What are the best ways to use it so you can ensure that none of it gets wasted? There are so many options.
Most people love putting toffee sauce on ice cream. It’s such a great topping that can make many different ice cream flavors better.
If you want to do something simple, you could dip apple slices in it. It’ll make eating an apple a day that much more of a treat.
Of course, other desserts such as brownies and cinnamon rolls will benefit from toffee sauce. Pour a bit of it on any dessert that seems compatible.
Some people even put it on pancakes or waffles. It could wind up making breakfast even more exciting than usual.
If you like eating pretzels, you should try dipping them in toffee sauce. Many people think that it’s rather tasty.
Finally, sweet popcorn goes surprisingly well with it. It could become a staple of your home movie nights.
Final Thoughts
You’ve learned that toffee sauce can be made without cream. Many recipes call for heavy cream, but you can substitute milk and have things turn out well.
It’s best to seek out a recipe that calls for milk, though. This ensures that you can make toffee sauce that will give you the right results.
Just be sure not to use too much milk. If you accidentally use too much, it’ll make the sauce turn out far too thin.
Enjoy your toffee sauce and be sure to share it with your family. You should feel confident enough to whip up this tasty sauce whenever you’re in the mood for a special treat.
Sarah is the founder of Baking Kneads, LLC, a blog sharing guides, tips, and recipes for those learning how to bake. Growing up as the daughter of a baker, she spent much of her childhood learning the basics in a local bakery.