Skip to Content

What Do Eggs Do in Cookies?

What Do Eggs Do in Cookies?

Share this post:

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click one of these links and make a purchase, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. In addition, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

When it comes to baking, there are several key ingredients that are included in just about every single recipe. There is often going to be flour, butter, and even milk in the majority of baking recipes out there. Most people can agree that these ingredients are the crux of baking.

With that being said there are some ingredients that are completely overlooked, despite their importance in baking. One of the most prominent examples of this is the egg.

In most forms of baking, eggs are included in the recipe. For people who follow a vegan diet, there is often an egg-like substitute that can be added that mimics the cooking properties of an egg. The reason for this is because eggs provide a lot more than just substance for your food.

Eggs are a key part of the baking process for a good reason. For example, consider the cookie. When you add extra eggs or if you don’t use enough eggs in the recipe, the cookie will come out significantly different.

One way to learn about what exactly eggs do in cooking is to consider how they can alter a common recipe. However, before you can look at how eggs alter cookies, you will need to have a good understanding of what exactly eggs bring to the table in baking and what properties they can add to your food.

What Is Inside the Egg?

Egg In A Bowl

There are actually two major parts to an egg that need to be considered during the cooking process, as both parts of the egg provide different properties. There are the egg whites, which is the translucent fluid that surrounds the yolk of the egg, and then there is the yolk of the egg.

Both parts of the egg are used in cooking, although some recipes will call for only an egg yolk or only egg whites.

First, you should have a good idea of what each part of the egg contains in regards to cooking and nutrients. The egg white is going to be mostly water and protein, which is one reason why adding eggs often moistens foods.

The egg yolk is mostly nutrients, vitamins, and fat. More often than not, it is included in recipes to add fat so that the recipe ends up working the way it is intended.

One thing to note about eggs is that despite just how many different types of eggs there are, most recipes will be working with large chicken eggs unless otherwise specified.

Most eggs will also weigh about two ounces total, with about one ounce being for the egg whites, two-thirds of an ounce being for the yolk, and the rest being the shell of an egg.

Some recipes will call for egg ingredients by weight rather than by the number of eggs needed. These are often more precise and finicky recipes, and it will be important for you to use the proper measurements.

You can rely on the general rule of thumb that eggs are two parts white to one part yolk when you decide to weigh the egg.

Now that you understand what makes up an egg, you need to understand how these properties affect cooking. From there, you can begin to understand what role eggs play in making the perfect cookies.

What Do Eggs Do to Food?

Fresh Batch Of Cookies

Eggs are an incredibly common ingredient and they are used for a variety of reasons. Some people use them to add taste to their meals while other people rely on the properties of the egg to make the recipe perfect.

To put things simply, eggs are added to food to add structure and stability, to thicken foods, and to add moisture to foods. Eggs are used for structure for batters and similar foods, they are used for thickening when it comes to sauces, and they add moisture to cakes and cookies.

Egg yolks and egg whites offer different properties, which is one of the reasons why some recipes will only call for egg whites or egg yolks, rather than whole eggs. Typically, egg yolks are used for their fat, which can help with texture, flavor, and binding liquids together.

On the other hand, egg whites are used to help with whipping foods, adding a light and airy texture to them.

Looking at Egg Yolks Specifically

Small Bowl Of Egg Yolks

Egg yolks, due to their fat content, will often help to bind liquids and fats together, allowing them to become a homogenous mixture that can be more easily repurposed throughout a recipe, such as making a smooth batter.

Less often, they are used for texture or adding flavor to foods, but there are still times when egg yolks are added to recipes for these reasons.

The way this works is that when an egg yolk is heated during the baking process, the proteins within the yolk will begin to unfold themselves and turn into a gel-like substance. This, mixed in with the other ingredients of a recipe, will thicken and smooth out the texture, allowing you to do different things with your food.

Recipes that rely on solely the egg yolk include custards, ice cream, crème brûlée, and curds. Solely egg yolks can sometimes include cakes, although some people rely on the egg whites as well because of the properties that those can bring.

Looking at Egg Whites Specifically

Separating Egg Whites From Yolks

In a sense, egg whites can be considered the opposite of an egg yolk. Egg whites are used during the whipping process to create foods that are light, airy, and almost foam-like compared to the thickening that egg yolks can do.

The whipping process involves whipping the ingredients together, allowing for millions upon millions of tiny little air bubbles to form, adding more volume to the food that you are working with. Most beginner bakers will learn that this is a delicate process, as there is certainly a thing as over-whipping food.

When that trapped air begins to expand in a hot oven, it begins to add even more volume to the food that you are working with. This is one reason why over-whipping food can lead to a disaster, as too many air bubbles expanding can alter the way the recipe is supposed to be.

When a recipe includes solely egg whites as opposed to a whole egg, it is often because you need to whip everything together.

Recipes that rely solely on egg whites include meringues, macarons, marshmallows, and some types of frosting. It is rarely used in heavier baked goods, as the weight of these ingredients do not allow the egg whites to create a foam.

Putting Everything Together Into a Cookie

Chocolate Cookie Dough

Now that you have a good understanding of what each part of an egg can add to a baking recipe, you can begin to understand the role of eggs in cookies, and what adding too little or too many can do to your recipe.

More often than not, you will be working with whole eggs for cookies, although there may be a select few recipes that call for only egg whites or only egg yolks.

In cookie dough, eggs are going to be a major source of moisture, as there aren’t many “wet” ingredients involved in these recipes. This means that the eggs are going to be the main component in binding together starch and flour. Eggs are going to be key in creating texture within the cookie.

More eggs mean that there will be more binding between starch and flour proteins. This means that there will be more texture to the cookie, with that texture often being chewy. If you enjoy chewy, almost cake-like cookies, then you will want to increase the number of eggs you include in your recipe.

Likewise, if you want to have thin, crunchy cookies, then you will want to substantially decrease the amount of egg you use. You will still need to use some eggs, as moisture is a necessary component in cookie dough, but if you want the thinnest cookies, you will want to use the minimal amount of egg necessary.

Egg yolks, specifically, will emulsify the cookie dough, thickening it and allowing it to whip slightly more efficiently than it otherwise would. Too few egg yolks will make it hard for the dough to spread, and the lack of moisture within the egg yolk will also leave the cookie with a drier texture than if you included egg whites.

Only using egg yolks without any egg whites will leave you with a harder cookie. Less egg yolks will turn the cookie into something akin to a stale, gritty muffin. More egg yolks will turn the cookie into something adjacent to cake.

Egg whites, specifically, will allow you to whip the cookie dough. It is immensely harder to cook cookies with only egg whites, meaning that the baking process is going to be prolonged. Adding only egg whites to your cookies is going to create dense and chewy cookies, with varying degrees of moisture depending on the number of egg whites used.

With all of this in mind, you can take to the kitchen and experiment with adding varying amounts of both egg yolks and egg whites to create the cookie of your dreams. Do keep in mind that, depending on the cookie recipe you are working with, the results may be slightly different than what you would otherwise expect.

Share this post: